Lygon Street is famously known as Melbourne’s Little Italy and for bloody good reason. This iconic street in Carlton serves up some of the most authentic Italian food you’ll find outside of Rome itself.

From family-run trattorias that have been dishing up Nonna’s recipes for decades to Italian restaurants putting fresh spins on classic dishes, Lygon Street delivers the goods every single time.

Whether you’re after a quick bite of proper wood-fired pizza or planning a long lunch with mates over handmade pasta, this famous food street has something to satisfy every craving.

The atmosphere along this bustling street captures the true spirit of Italian dining – it’s all about sharing great food with the people you love most.

We’ve done the hard yakka for you, trying Italian food from many restaurants to bring you the seven best Italian restaurants in Lygon Street that’ll have you coming back for more.            

Best Italian Restaurants in Lygon Street

1. Da Guido La Pasta

Google Rating: 4.6

Located at 130 Lygon Street, Da Guido La Pasta brings a refined take on Italian dining with a focus on handmade pasta and seasonal ingredients.

The menu is full of flavor, but the gnocchi truly stood out—light, soft, and paired with slow-cooked beef that melts in your mouth.

Also, the Wagyu ravioli, topped with truffle, sauce, and cheese, is rich and perfectly balanced.

If you’re feeling adventurous, try the squid ink pasta—unique and delicious.

The atmosphere is warm and stylish, with painted brick walls, elegant glassware, and modern light fixtures.

Terrace seating offers peaceful views of Lincoln Square, adding a calming touch to the meal.

From the attentive staff to the fine details in the presentation, everything feels thoughtfully done. Da Guido is perfect for both special occasions and casual nights out.

2. Tiamo

Google Rating: 4.3

Located at 303 Lygon Street, Tiamo has been serving authentic, home-style Italian meals for over 40 years.

This Italian restaurant in Lygon Street is all about comfort food done right. Here you’ll get creamy mushroom pasta, rich spaghetti marinara, and perfectly layered lasagna.

Their handmade mushroom pasta is truly amazing. It’s silky, firm, and packed with deep, earthy flavor.

The Fungi pizza and Caprese special are also delicious, both fresh and satisfying. Even the Caesar salad is full of flavor, thanks to the generous Parmesan.

The service stood out too—friendly, efficient and never rushed. It’s a space that feels relaxed but still professional.

Prices are fair, especially considering the quality and portion sizes. Whether you’re craving pizza, pasta, or salad, Tiamo delivers in every way.

3. Universal Restaurant

Google Rating: 4.4

Located at 141 Lygon Street, Universal Restaurant has been a local favorite Italian restaurant since 1969.

This is where you go for hearty, satisfying Italian food that doesn’t hold back.

Their pizzas are a real highlight—chewy, flavorful dough with just the right amount of crisp.

Also, try their chicken schnitzel. It’s huge, juicy, and full of flavor. While the chicken Parma is so big, you might want to share it.

If you’re after pasta, the Bolognese is simple and comforting, and the mortadella pizza offers a savory twist with a perfectly crisp base.

The vibe inside is cheerful and welcoming, with a smart layout that makes the most of the space.

Best of all, the value is unbeatable—big servings at prices that won’t hurt your wallet. Universal is the kind of place you’ll want to return to with friends or family.

Also Read: Best Italian Restaurants in Carlton

4. IL Gambero

Google Rating: 4.3

Located at 166 Lygon Street, IL Gambero has been serving Italian comfort food since 1975.

This authentic Italian restaurant in Lygon Street is cozy yet spacious, making it a great place for casual dining with family or friends.

The food is flavorful and satisfying, especially their mushroom risotto — creamy, rich, and absolutely delicious.

Also, their pasta dishes are amazing, cooked just right and packed with a homemade feel.

IL Gambero is not fancy or flashy, but that’s exactly what gives it charm. It feels like a true local spot where you can relax and enjoy a good meal.

They’re also great at accommodating dietary needs — their cheese-free pizza was a pleasant surprise. The garlic prawns on rice are another must-try. If you prefer mild Italian flavors in a laid-back setting, IL Gambero is a solid choice.

5. La Spaghettata Restaurant

Google Rating: 4.1

La Spaghettata Restaurant, located at 238 Lygon Street, is a cozy and welcoming Italian food spot with a warm, relaxed atmosphere.

It’s one of the best restaurants in Lygon Street for Italian food, especially on a pleasant evening, thanks to the outdoor seating.

The food is delicious across the board — from the rich marinara pasta to the crisp salad and smooth tiramisu. The sangria pairs perfectly with it all.

One dish that really stands out is the Spaghettata oysters, topped with melted cheese and a tangy tomato-style relish.

Their pasta plate is generous and affordable, and the gluten-free pasta is one of the best around —flavorful and satisfying. Whether you’re looking for a comforting meal or a great place to hang out, La Spaghettata delivers on taste and experience.

6. Johnny, Vince and Sam’s Ristorante

Google Rating: 4.6

Johnny, Vince and Sam’s Ristorante is located at 306-308 Lygon Street and offers a unique mix of great food and retro charm.

With a dining capacity of over 100 diners, it feels lively and full of character.

Their meatball pasta is a local favorite — rich, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. Also, their pasta Al Forno and fennel salad are worth ordering.

The atmosphere makes the place extra special. It’s like stepping into the 1960s, with décor and music that spark a bit of nostalgia.

The staff are friendly and attentive, which adds to the welcoming vibe.

Whether you’re out for a fun dinner or celebrating something special, this spot makes it memorable.

From its tasty menu to its energetic setting, this Italian ristorante is a standout on Lygon Street.

7. Piccolo Mondo

Google Rating: 4.4

Piccolo Mondo, located at 240 Lygon Street, is a stylish, family-owned Italian restaurant that delivers both taste and authenticity.

The pasta is fresh and flavorful, and the mussels are a real treat — local, perfectly sized, and served in a zesty tomato sauce with just the right amount of chili.

Every Italian dish at Piccolo Mondo feels thoughtfully made and will make you feel as if you are in Italy!

Popular menu items like chicken cacciatore, lasagna, ravioli, and rigatoni with meatballs come in generous portions and arrive piping hot.

The flavors are bold and comforting, like a home-cooked meal.

Their pizza is also a standout — thin, crisp, and packed with flavor, just the way traditional Italian pizza should be.

If you’re after a hearty, honest Italian meal in a warm setting, Piccolo Mondo won’t disappoint.