Byron Bay isn’t just about the surf and sunsets – it’s got some seriously good pizza too.

Living here, you quickly learn which pizza spots are actually worth your time, and which ones keep locals coming back week after week.

From wood-fired pizzas with a bit of char on the crust to fresh toppings pulled straight from nearby farms, Byron has its own way of doing pizza that feels honest and full of flavor.

I’ve spent years eating my way around town, and a few pizza places always rise above the rest. Some are perfect for a quick lunch after the beach, while others feel right for a lively night with mates.

Here are my eight picks for the best pizza in Byron Bay – the ones I’d happily recommend to anyone who asks where to find a proper slice.

Best Pizza in Byron Bay

1- Bay Pizza Lab

Google Rating: 4.6

Located at Shop 4/5/2 Fletcher Street, Bay Pizza Lab has honestly earned its reputation as one of the best pizza places in Byron Bay.

The pizzeria has a relaxed and unpretentious vibe, making it perfect for anyone who appreciates authentic Italian flavors without the fuss.

Grab a seat by the window to enjoy the ocean breeze and watch the lively Byron Bay streets as you wait for your pizza.

The pizza dough here is exceptional—thin, fluffy, and perfectly balanced with just the right crispness.

Their Margherita and Sausage pizzas are highly recommended, with rich flavors that truly define their Italian roots.

If you are a cheese lover, you should try the Four Cheese pizza, while vegetarians can opt for the mushie or pumpkin pizzas.

Seafood fans will enjoy the tuna pizza, which is equally flavorful. Also, don’t forget to try their smoked cheese and garlic aioli dip—it takes your pizza experience to the next level.

Also, arrive early as this place gets busy for a reason.

2- Il Buco Cafe & Pizzeria

Google Rating: 4.4

Located at 4/4 Bay Lane, Il Buco Cafe & Pizzeria offers a genuine Italian dining experience right in the heart of Byron Bay.

This pizza spot in Byron Bay has more outdoor seating than indoor, and its vibrant atmosphere makes it a favorite among locals and tourists.

The pizzas are made with authentic Italian dough and topped generously, resulting in a truly delicious wood-fired taste.

If you’re unsure what to order, the Margherita and Quattro Stagioni are safe bets.

The Prosciutto Funghi, featuring ham and mushrooms, is another must-order pizza on the menu.

True pizza lovers shouldn’t miss the Salame Inferno with hot salami, while vegetarians should order the Vegetariana, which has olives, artichokes, and seasonal roasted vegetables.

If you are a vegan, you can order the Marinara pizza, a cheese-free option with fresh tomato passata, garlic, basil, and chili.

Il Buco is BYO alcohol, and the fairy lights and occasional live music add to its charm. With limited seating and no reservations, plan to arrive early.

Also Read: Best Coffee in Byron Bay

3- Slice Pizzeria

Google Rating: 4.6

Located at 5/4 Jonson Street, Slice Pizzeria is a go-to spot in Byron Bay for no-fuss, great-tasting pizzas.

Their pizzas are wood-fired to perfection, with a crisp, slightly charred crust that complements a variety of toppings.

The pizza menu caters to all tastes, offering plenty of vegetarian and meat options. Popular choices include the Bolognese and Meat Lovers pizzas, both hearty and flavorful.

Seafood fans will love the Game of Prawns pizza, while those looking for something different can try the Capricciosa pizza.

Slice Pizzeria also serves Pepperita, BBQ Chicken, and Pulled Pork pizzas, making it hard to choose just one.

If you’re ordering a family-size pizza, be prepared for generously sized slices with lots of toppings—rolling them up might be the easiest way to enjoy.

Slice Pizzeria is indeed one of the best pizza spots in Byron Bay for both dine out and takeaway, perfect when you want a satisfying meal without any unnecessary extras.

4- Treehouse

Google Rating: 4.3

Located at 25 Childe Street, Treehouse combines a relaxed coastal vibe with seriously good pizza.

The restaurant is set in a charming building surrounded by trees, with outdoor seating that perfectly matches its laid-back atmosphere.

After your pizza meal, you can stroll across the road to the beach, making it an ideal Byron Bay experience.

Their wood-fired pizzas feature hand-spun bases and house-made Napoli sauce, giving each pizza slice a fresh and authentic taste.

We highly recommend trying the Isle of Capri, topped with buffalo mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, basil, oregano, and garlic oil.

For classic choices, their Margherita and Capricciosa pizzas are fantastic.

Want to order something unusual? Order their Island Vibes pizza, while meat lovers can order the wagyu bresaola or pepperoni pizza.

If you love a pizza with prawns, you must try the Pimpin’ Shrimpin’ pizza, which is just as fun as it sounds.

Treehouse is slightly away from Byron’s central bustle, offering a peaceful spot to enjoy amazing pizza.

5- Trattoria Basiloco

Google Rating: 4.4

Located at 32 Lawson Street, Trattoria Basiloco is a family-owned Italian restaurant that serves some of the most authentic pizzas in Byron Bay.

The atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, with both indoor and outdoor seating options. Sitting outside under cover gives you a chance to enjoy the lively Byron vibe while having a comfortable dining experience.

Parking is available right out front, with free parking after 6 p.m., which makes it convenient for dinner plans.

The real highlight of Trattoria Basiloco is its wood-fired pizzas. The dough is exceptionally light and flavorful, with the perfect chewy texture.

Their Margherita pizza is one of the best in town—simple, traditional, and delicious. If you want to explore more flavors, try their Bufalina or Diavola for a true taste of Italy.

Meat lovers should not miss the Salsiccia or Capricciosa pizzas, while even the Hawaiiana is great. Gluten-free bases are also available, making it a great option for everyone.

Dining here feels like enjoying pizza straight from Italy.

Also Explore: Best Things to Do in Byron Bay

6- Pizza Paradiso Pizzeria & Bodegón

Google Rating: 4.3

Pizza Paradiso Pizzeria, located at 1 Clifford Street, is another top-rated pizza place in Byron Bay that is a must-visit for pizza lovers.

Known for its thin, crispy crust and flavorful pizza dough, this place delivers on both quality and taste. You can dine in or take away, making it a flexible option depending on your plans.

The friendly staff and retro 80’s playlist add a fun and laid-back vibe to the experience. The outdoor heating also makes it comfortable on cooler evenings.

All pizzas here are made with Paradiso’s own tomato base and Byron Bay mozzarella, which gives them a signature flavor.

Their Margherita with bocconcini, parmesan, and basil is simple yet excellent.

For something heartier, you can order the Supremo pizza that has ham, pepperoni, onion, mushrooms, capsicum, and olives.

Meat lovers will enjoy the Carnivore pizza loaded with beef, pepperoni, ham, and bacon.

If you love spicy flavors, try the Mt Warning pizza—it’s one of the spiciest pizzas you’ll find in Byron Bay.

With large and giant sizes available, Paradiso is the perfect pizza spot in Byron Bay for groups or big appetites.

7- Ciao, Mate!

Google Rating: 4.6

Located at 33 Byron Street, Ciao, Mate! is a must-visit for anyone who appreciates well-made pizza with amazing flavors.

This pizza restaurant in Byron Bay has built a strong reputation for delivering some of the best pizzas in Byron Bay.

The casual yet trendy setting makes it ideal for both locals and tourists looking for a great meal.

If you’re staying nearby in Byron, Federal, or Mullumbimby, it’s well worth the short drive to Bangalow for a visit. Booking ahead is recommended, as it’s often busy.

The Pepperoni pizza here is a must-order with La Boqueria pepperoni, smoked hot honey, oregano, and mozzarella—it’s a perfect mix of savory and slightly sweet.

Their Margherita and Alfredo pizzas are equally impressive for those who prefer classic flavors.

For a meatier option, the Spicy Italian Sausage or Lamb Supreme pizzas are fantastic. Even their Woodfired Peppers pizza is worth trying if you enjoy smoky, charred toppings.

Also Read: Best Breakfast in Byron Bay

8- Legend Pizza

Google Rating: 4.1

Legend Pizza, located at 2/3 Marvell Street, has been a Byron Bay pizza institution since 1992.

Owned by locals Scott and Gemma Levy, it offers a relaxed and friendly dining atmosphere right in the heart of Byron Bay.

Whether you want to eat in, take away, or have it delivered, Legend Pizza makes it easy. They also offer free BYO, making it a great option for casual get-togethers.

The pizza menu is extensive and thoughtfully organized into categories like meat, vegetarian, chicken, ocean, spicy, and basic pizzas.

For meat lovers, the Supreme Legend, Meaty Legend, and Pepperoni Legend pizzas are top picks.

Vegetarian options include the Garlic Mushroom Legend pizza and New York Legend pizza, which are flavorful and satisfying.

If you enjoy chicken pizzas, try the BBQ Chicken Legend, Malaysian Satay Legend, or Tandoori Chicken Legend pizzas for unique flavors.

Seafood lovers should order the Bay Legend pizza or Boardrider Legend pizza, while spice fans will love the Mexican Legend pizza or Red Devil Legend pizza.